Product · Ask

One question, opened all the way down

Ask takes an industry question and returns an answer in which every sentence that asserts a fact points at a passage in a primary source. This page shows one such answer, the work that produced it, and the claim the validator refused to let through.

Modes

Three ways to ask, and what each one costs.

The mode is chosen before the question runs and is recorded with the answer. Quick and Deliberate differ in how long synthesis deliberates; the citation check is the same in both.

Quick

mode=speculative

Retrieval-first synthesis. Same citation validation, less deliberation.

Wall time
~30 s
Per query
~$0.01

Deliberate

the sample below

mode=deliberate

The full specialist pipeline — deeper retrieval, longer synthesis.

Wall time
1–2 min
Per query
~$0.10

Conversational

POST /v1/tutor · follow-up turns

A session you can keep asking into. Every turn is cited the same way.

Wall time
follow-ups
Per query
~$0.01

published wall-time expectation and per-query price for each mode · not a measurement of any run

The work, made visible

What a reader watches while the question runs.

Ask streams its progress. The coordinator reports 13 named stages over the response as NDJSON frames, and each of them advances exactly one of the five rows below — so a row only ever moves because a frame said it did. Nothing is estimated forward.

five reader rows and the 13 Ask wire stages that drive them · durations are measured medians of past deliberate runs, not this page's run

Before the first frame, the clock is the only fact

Until a frame arrives, the only real number on screen is the elapsed wall clock. The stepper is driven by the typical timings above and is labelled as such, and it is held short of the last row: a progress display may not show the answer saved before the answer has arrived.

typical timing — this run reported no stage frames

Cancel stops the waiting, not the work

Cancelling aborts the request to the API, and the abort really does reach the upstream fetch. It does not stop the pipeline: the run finishes and the answer is persisted. The work is kept, so asking the same question again returns it rather than running it a second time — the first stage below is that check.

idempotency_lookup · hit → the stored answer is returned

The answer

One answered question, with its claims.

Everything from here to the end of the withheld claim is an illustrative sample: it was written to show the format and was never produced by the engine. It carries no date, because a date would be a claim that something happened.

Illustrative sample

not engine output · not a delivery · not dated

No answer is published to the public sample endpoint. Every ad-hoc answer in the showcase workspace is agent traffic rather than content chosen for publication, and publishing whichever one is newest is the rule we removed. So the prose below is hand-authored to show the shape — the numbered claims, the sources rail, the withheld block — and the only counted numbers on this page are the validator's, at the foot.

Forum Atlas / ask · ForumEnergy · ForumTechdeliberate

Question

How do PJM capacity prices affect Virginia data-center buildouts?

answer · 6 citations · 6 verified · 1 withheld

PJM's Base Residual Auction sets the price Virginia load-serving entities pay for generation availability. The 2025/26 auction cleared at $269.92/MW-day RTO-wide, roughly nine times the prior year 1; the 2026/27 auction cleared at the $329.17 collar agreed in the FERC settlement 23.

Dominion Energy Virginia is the largest load zone affected. Dominion reported approximately 40 GW of contracted data-center capacity in its pipeline at year-end 2024 4, and its 2024 Integrated Resource Plan filed with the Virginia SCC projects zone load roughly doubling by 2039 5. Capacity costs are passed through to customers via rate adjustment clauses 6.

WithheldEffect of 2026/27 prices on 2027 construction starts — no verbatim match found in corpus after two validation passes. insufficient_evidence

Challenge (private review aid)Add to caseExport · DOCX PPTX MD

sample answer in the signed-in register · illustrative

Sources cited

  1. 1PJM Interconnection2025/2026 Base Residual Auction Report2 passages
  2. 2PJM Interconnection2026/2027 Base Residual Auction Report1 passage
  3. 3FERCOrder accepting settlement, Docket EL25-461 passage
  4. 4Dominion EnergyForm 10-K, fiscal 20243 passages
  5. 5Virginia SCCDominion 2024 Integrated Resource Plan2 passages
  6. 6Virginia SCCRate adjustment clause filings1 passage

6 sources · 10 passages matched

sources rail as a delivered answer renders it · illustrative

Provenance

One claim, followed to the passage behind it.

Clicking a numbered claim in a delivered answer opens this chain. It is the whole product in one figure: five rungs from the sentence you read to the exact substring of the document it was matched against, each rung independently addressable.

provenance chain for one claim · the verbatim rung is empty because this sample has no source document · illustrative

The two lower rungs carry no text here on purpose. A verbatim span is a quotation from a real filing, and writing one for a sample would put an invented quotation under a named 10-K on the page whose entire subject is that we do not do that. In a delivered answer both rungs are filled from the retrieved chunk, and the match is an exact substring — paraphrase does not pass. Citation discipline sets out the check.

What was withheld

The claim that did not make it into the answer.

A withheld claim is not a defect in the answer. It is the evidence that the check is load-bearing — a validator that never withholds anything is not being used.

Withheldinsufficient_evidencevalidate 2 of 2

Effect of 2026/27 prices on 2027 construction starts

No verbatim match found in corpus after two validation passes. The model drafted this claim; the corpus did not support it as written. It was removed from the answer rather than softened, hedged or rewritten until it passed, and the rest of the answer stands unchanged.

validate 1 of 2retry · strict quotevalidate 2 of 2withheld

the sample answer's withheld claim and its two failed passes · illustrative

Counted, not illustrated

How often the validator actually withholds.

The sample above shows one withheld claim because the format has one. These are the real counts, read from the production database when this page was rendered. They are the only numbers on this page that describe something that happened.

1,733

passed validation

every claim matched a verbatim passage

queried 2026-10-19 06:03 UTC

597

withheld

no verbatim match after two passes

queried 2026-10-19 06:03 UTC

25.6%

withhold rate

of 2,330 through the validator

queried 2026-10-19 06:03 UTC

briefs through the validator, showcase workspace, all time · counted 2026-10-19 06:03 UTC

A brief counts once, in the state it finished in. We publish the withhold rate because a reader cannot judge the briefs that passed without knowing how many did not. Transparency carries the same counts beside the corpus and citation figures.

Ask is metered per query at the prices above. A question that returns nothing the corpus supports returns nothing, and says so.

Start free How a claim gets made